Big Walk used artificial intelligence to fix a bug. Now, the indie game scene is facing a reckoning.

Over the past few years, there has been intense debate regarding the widespread use of artificial intelligence tools in game development and how such usage should be responsibly disclosed to players. This week, the debate escalated into a full-blown controversy within the independent game development community when House House—the developer behind the popular cooperative puzzle-exploration game Big Walk—belatedly disclosed that they had used AI to a limited extent in the game’s creation.
The controversy had been brewing behind the scenes for months, with judges for the prestigious Independent Games Festival (IGF) discussing the issue in private forums. The debate went public on Monday, when 19 of the more than 50 judges issued a joint statement declaring their position: they would “refuse to vote for any game that uses generative AI in any form.”
Noting a “significant increase in the number of submitted games that utilize generative AI tools,” the judges highlighted the ecological, economic, psychological, and labor-related harms associated with AI. They rejected the use of these tools, asserting that their integration into the industry is by no means a “done deal.”
The judges also urged the Independent Games Festival to “adopt a strong anti-AI policy in the coming years, prohibiting any games that contain AI-generated content.”
A Major Retraction
Although the judges’ statement did not name any specific titles, by Tuesday morning, one highly acclaimed game had become the focal point of the controversy. In a statement provided to Aftermath—which was shortly thereafter added to the game’s FAQ page—developer House House openly admitted that, during the later stages of Big Walk‘s development, they “used LLMs to a limited extent to help solve some tricky technical problems and bugs.”
House House stated that the use of artificial intelligence was very limited, accounting for less than 0.1% of the code in Big Walk. This was partly due to a tricky bug in the Unity engine that caused “infinitely long” shadows to appear in certain scenes, which slowed down the game. After consulting a Unity engineer—who deemed the issue “unfixable”—House House turned to an LLM chatbot. The chatbot suggested a potential solution, though the developers had to “heavily modify” the resulting 10 lines of code that ultimately made it into the final game. (That said, at least one social media user has pointed out that the bug could, in fact, have been fixed through a significant amount of manual effort.)
House House explained that they did not disclose the use of an LLM during the development of Big Walk—which was released on Steam earlier this year—because Valve “does not require the disclosure of code or the use of chatbots.” In fact, Valve’s AI disclosure form for developers explicitly states that it focuses on AI-generated content, rather than the “efficiency gains” provided by “modern game development environments that incorporate AI tools.”
However, the IGF (Independent Games Festival) awards do not make such a distinction regarding the use of artificial intelligence. Consequently, when submitting Big Walk for consideration, House House specifically noted their use of AI to assist in fixing bugs. House House stated that they are disclosing this information now because “it has become a point of public concern.”
“This is not an endorsement or support for the use of AI tools—no matter how minor,” House House wrote. “We are concerned that voluntary disclosures like this might contribute to the normalization of this technology, or lead to it being perceived as ‘inevitable.’ We support the work of those striving to limit the harm caused by generative AI to video games and our world, and we apologize that our use of an LLM in Big Walk may not align with their standards.”
All or Nothing
Upon learning of House House’s disclosure regarding their use of AI, some IGF judges—who had previously held a special affection for Big Walk—felt particularly disheartened. In a blog post, IGF judge Austin Walker described the game as “an extraordinary achievement,” “stunning,” and “gorgeous,” noting that its puzzle design “explores a richness of play rarely seen in the medium of digital games.” Another judge, Damon Reece, shared in his own post that the game “meant a great deal” to him, evoking “a sense of home” and resonating with him “deeply and intensely.”
Yet, when it comes to the IGF awards, Walker, Reece, and others indicated that even the most minimal use of AI tools outweighs their profound respect for the work itself.
“We have the agency,” Reece wrote. “This pain is something that must be endured—to steer our culture away from its current state. We need to speak out, state our position clearly, and prioritize human creativity and labor—making it known to society and the world that such behavior is unacceptable to us. To do otherwise would be nothing short of cowardice.”
This is not the first time the use of artificial intelligence has significantly impacted the judging of gaming awards. Last year, the Independent Game Awards (which are entirely separate from the IGF Awards) rescinded an award given to Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 after the developer admitted that AI tools had been used to create some of the game’s textures (these textures were later replaced via a patch).
“The Independent Game Awards maintains a firm stance against the use of artificial intelligence throughout the nomination process and the awards ceremony,” they stated at the time.
We all make mistakes.
Since House House publicly disclosed the matter, those among the IGF judges who oppose the use of AI have found support from many disappointed Big Walk fans and industry insiders. In recent days, the game’s Steam page has been hit by over 400 negative reviews—though Steam’s anti-review-bombing mechanisms appear to have limited the impact of these critiques on the game’s overall “Overwhelmingly Positive” rating.
Others, however, argue that House House’s use of AI in the game is relatively minor and has been blown out of proportion. They point out that it is crucial to distinguish between games that use Large Language Models (LLMs) as a marginal technical tool, and those that rely heavily on AI to generate the bulk of their art, music, or core engine code.
IGF judge Liz Ryerson wrote on social media that she believes the use of AI by House House was cited as a reason to disqualify the game from an award, adding, “It really bothers me that so many people act as if there’s no distinction—as if it’s all the same thing.”
“What troubles me,” she wrote, “is that some people end up being punished more severely for being honest about a minor mistake, while others choose not to attempt honesty or transparency at all.”
Dominic Tarason, a writer for Steam Hype and a veteran Steam curator, also pushed back against the punitive “zero-tolerance” stance—the idea that House House should be completely shunned and their work never mentioned again. He described Big Walk as a “slightly flawed work of art,” yet one that remains “absolutely, undeniably art—and deeply human.”
“They spent years creating that piece of art,” Tarassen added, “and then they spent two minutes asking a chatbot how to fix a bug. It’s a ‘come on, don’t do that’ kind of failure—not a crime against humanity that warrants throwing someone into the darkest dungeon until nothing but ashes remain.”
Others, however, argue that using AI to fix bugs—rather than hiring an expert to identify the underlying issues—strips a bit of the human element from the game development process. “House House didn’t lay off developers to replace them with Claude (an AI)—and I’m sure they would strongly oppose such a practice—but it’s clear that their actions contribute to the very same problem,” AI researcher Mike Cook wrote on his blog.
Meanwhile, game developer, author, and professor Brendan Keogh argues that an extreme, zero-tolerance stance toward all forms of generative AI may ultimately prove counterproductive. “Many people are lashing out at developers who—feeling conflicted about using tools akin to a Google search—chose to be transparent about it. This only encourages others to use such tools covertly, effectively obscuring the exploitation of labor.”
As AI tools become increasingly integrated into the development of mainstream game engines, it will become ever more difficult for those who staunchly oppose AI to avoid games that contain even a trace of AI-generated code—even when such usage is disclosed upfront. Nevertheless, many remain convinced that taking a firm, public stand against what they view as a scourge on the industry is essential.
“I believe a zero-tolerance stance is a viable political position,” narrative designer and writer Hannah Nicklin wrote on social media. “You can engage in political action to challenge systems, advocate for people, and drive change through connection and understanding. The statement from the Independent Games Festival jury… centers on a framework of shared values and calls for change, fostering solidarity rooted in a commitment to harm reduction.”